All AC Shadows Choices That Matter

How Choices Impact Assassin’s Creed Shadows

Assassin’s Creed Shadows offers a surprisingly intricate system of player choices, although not all of them significantly alter the gameplay. While many dialogue options and actions lead to slight narrative variations, influencing character reactions, only a few choices have noticeable impacts on the overall experience. These key decisions shape character relationships, mission progression, and even the overarching story arc in subtle, but meaningful ways.

All Assassin’s Creed Shadows Choices that Impact Gameplay

Four major decisions and one minor choice within Assassin’s Creed Shadows significantly alter the game’s trajectory. These critical points dictate different narrative threads, NPCs’ interactions, and even character recruitment paths. Let’s delve into these pivotal moments that shape your experience.

Major Choices

Confront Otama or Wakasa (Tea Ceremony Quest)

• Confront Otama: This choice leads to a direct confrontation with Otama and a subsequent assassination. This revelation directs you towards Wakasa, setting a different path for pursuing the Golden Teppo.
• Confront Wakasa: Naoe will confront Wakasa, revealing her as the Golden Teppo, and allowing for immediate assassination.

Critical Note: Completing this quest requires four out of five specific dialogue options. Missing even one will prevent you from encountering Wakasa’s option.

Side with Mitsumune or Not (Heads Will Roll Quest)

• Side with Mitsumune (Canon): The soldiers will be killed, but Yaya’s favor is impacted.
• Don’t Side with Mitsumune: The soldiers will be killed, but you gain Yaya’s favor. This becomes important in later recruitment opportunities.

Forgive or Punish the Shrine Raiders (The Stray Dogs Quests)

• Forgive the Shrine Raiders (Canon): This decision maintains a positive relationship with Yaya.
• Punish the Shrine Raiders: While not harmful, it does not enhance any further relationships.

Forgive Tetsuo or Take Responsibility (The Stray Dogs Quest)

• Forgive Tetsuo (Canon): Preserving the relationship with Yaya is key and beneficial in later missions.
• Take Responsibility: This action doesn’t negatively impact the storyline, but it misses a chance for positive relationship growth.

Minor Choice

Spare or Kill the Gamemaker (The Butterfly Collector Quest)

• Kill the Gamemaker: This choice is a straightforward action with no direct or meaningful consequences.
• Spare the Gamemaker (Canon): This decision unlocks the Butterfly of Benevolence and has no significant repercussions on the gameplay.

In summary, these choices are crucial moments that direct gameplay in various subtle ways, not just leading to different narrative outcomes but also affecting character development and relationships within Assassin’s Creed Shadows.